Feather of Ma'at
1,082 downloads

- Release date
- 20-Mar-2013
- File size
- 103 MB
- Class
- Egypt
- Engine
- TR4
- Duration
- long
- Difficulty
- challenging
Review scores
Read the comments ↓| Reviewer | Gameplay & Puzzles | Enemies, Objects & Secrets | Atmosphere, Sound & Cameras | Lighting & Textures |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bigfoot ↓ | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 |
| DJ Full ↓ | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 |
| Drakan ↓ | 9 | 9 | 10 | 9 |
| eRIC ↓ | 8 | 8 | 9 | 9 |
| eTux ↓ | 7 | 8 | 9 | 8 |
| izzynoodles ↓ | 8 | 8 | 10 | 10 |
| Jay ↓ | 8 | 8 | 9 | 9 |
| Jose ↓ | 8 | 9 | 10 | 9 |
| Josey ↓ | 8 | 10 | 10 | 9 |
| manarch2 ↓ | 8 | 8 | 9 | 9 |
| nerdfury ↓ | 7 | 8 | 9 | 8 |
| Phil ↓ | 9 | 8 | 8 | 8 |
| Ryan ↓ | 9 | 8 | 9 | 8 |
| Treeble ↓ | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 |
| Category averages (14 reviews) | 8.36 | 8.57 | 9.29 | 8.86 |
The gameplay initially isn't very exciting; however the 2nd half, inside the temple, is good fun. There's quite a few exciting trap sequences in the 2nd half, but in general the level still has too much "running around pulling levers" gameplay. There is one specific gameplay task that disrupts flow: a color puzzle within the temple. From left to right we have 3 color guides: first, aqua (use blue + green levers to make aqua; this is logical), then we have purple (use blue + red levers to make purple; this is logical), then finally we have yellow. For the yellow color guide, the correct lever combination is green + red and this does NOT make sense, and in my opinion it ruins a creative and refreshing concept. Object decor is beautiful, particularly the flora outside, although I'm not a huge fan of using small/harmless enemies, such as bats, over and over. You might as well not have them at all, if they're just going to tickle Lara and die super quick. On the flip side, the wraith inside the temple was utilized very effectively. The atmosphere is truly spectacular, and the builder demonstrates a very high skill in creating organic geometry where the player really feels like they are immersed within decaying ruins. The eerie and mysterious background music within the temple is an excellent fit, and lighting/texturing is mostly of a very high standard, with occasional misshapen triangular tiles (these occasional mishaps do occur across all 3 levels). I feel like there should have been better visibility inside the temple, i.e. more contrast so that geometry is easier to identify, and more feasible sources of dynamic light (torches, sunrays seeping in through ceilings, etc.).
Level 2 -Al Rachun (7/8/9/9)
This level has a slower pace; it's very heavy on exploration and is lacking in action and excitement (the small/harmless bat enemies from level 1 are now replaced by small/harmless spiders). I had fun for the most part, although I missed the spicy traps from the first level. There's a wonderful, highly creative "dropping 3 boulders" puzzle that I think is the gameplay highlight of the entire levelset. The only gameplay aspect that I did not enjoy were 2 timed runs, in the same area, near the end of the level. They need to be done in a certain order, but the builder does not communicate this at all. So, there's a good chance that the player will have performed the wrong timed run, for nothing. It is bad game design to have the player put in the effort to make a timed run, and then get slapped in the face by entering a room in which they cannot progress. The atmosphere is just as impressive as in level 1, however I think with a bit more effort with geometry boundaries, the builder could have avoided a number of "end of the world" moments. Immersion remains high, due to effective use of static object decor and "ruined" geometry. Also enhancing the atmosphere is a nice little cutscene of a magical force, shooting out a boulder, in order to shatter a stone slab. There is a timed run underground, near crawlspaces and watery caves, that absolutely needs a tense sound cue or some other indicator that it is timed (there are a couple of other timed runs that could also use indicators, but they are not as essential). It's a breathtakingly beautiful level, and even though I was exploring underground at times, I never felt worn out by the darkness due to there being plenty of varied exploration; underground, then outside, underground, then outside, etc. I did feel like sometimes the builder used colored lighting just for the sake of using it, even when it doesn't really fit the builder's realistic visual theme. Sometimes, the builder's colored lighting works beautifully; for example, the snake talisman temple has eerie red colored lighting and it works perfectly to build suspense. Other times, out in the Egyptian desert, there will be a few random green blobs of colored lighting, and they just look out of place.
Level 3 -Inside the Complex (8/8/8/7)
I started to feel like finishing this level became a "job" as opposed to being "fun". The gameplay isn't bad in any way; the gameplay here is rated higher because I think the flow is the most logical out of the 3 levels. I just felt like I was repeating not-so-interesting tasks, climbing lots of long ladders, etc., all in a horribly dark environment. I had amassed plenty of flares at this point, but it's just not fun for me to be lighting them over and over. Level 2 was wonderful in terms of visual and lighting variety, and in comparison level 3 really lacked this. As with the 2nd half of level 1, I think level 3 needed more feasible sources of varied light, acting breathers from all of the darkness. There is a timed run near the end of the game (around the pyramid) and it's really bad that there is no indication to the player that it's timed.
Overall, the 2nd half of level 1 had some exciting trap setups, and I was disappointed that levels 2 and 3 never equaled or surpassed this excitement. There are certainly some good moments to be found in this levelset, but there's also quite a lot of dull moments with plenty of running around pulling levers/climbing ladders. There's also a few "???" moments in terms of player-friendliness. I would highly recommend this levelset to new/learning builders, not necessarily for the gameplay, but for the amazing architectural design and environmental immersion. A case study for creating organic geometry, if that makes sense. Average of 3 ratings, using a value of .5 to round up or down: 7/8/9/8. P.S. "Examination of the Sphinx'' is very similar in aesthetic style, however I think it has more engaging gameplay than "Feather of Ma'at"." - nerdfury
Al-Rachun (8-7-10-9) - 45 minutes: The start of this level is already a highlight, with the sandy desert Lara shortly leaves to enter a deserted temple area (not even a single human enemy roaming around). While this enhances the isolated feeling of this site I'd say that I really missed some fights in here, even more so than in the last level, as the gameplay is not very action-based, mostly about exploring the huge setting, and a little "alternation" would've been nice this way; the scarabs and bats alone did not make up this feeling. There were a few good ideas with the gameplay (like the two blocks where one serves to create a "bridge" and the other having a double usage) and in general I quite enjoyed my time in this level (mostly because of the great setting), but it certainly lacks more gripping gameplay. There is a point in this level where things pick up slightly - when falling deep down after a fun timed run you'll be enjoying doing some good puzzles underground. I admit the end of the world is easily reached a few times but when knowing you don't have to climb any higher ledges in the "natural" outdoor areas it won't be an issue and the atmosphere is too great in my opinion to downrate it because of that.
Inside the Complex (7-8-8-9) - 40 minutes: The level I liked least especially from an aesthetic point of view, since most of the areas look pretty alike and I didn't really get warmed up to the setting. It's still professionally done with good texturing, though somewhat uniform lighting, and a nice architecture. Even the gameplay is not really to my taste with definately too many switches to find and often dull progression. The torch sequence and the platforming in the lava room are definately better moments but good ideas like those are rather few in the level. Later on, there were a few more memorable things like the nice timed run in the pyramid room the breakable tile challenge and the elevator, both including a well hidden secret each. I also liked the "fire demigods" eTux already mentioned and all timed challenges add to the fun, but the level as a whole felt rather underwhelming because of the mentioned rather unexiting gameplay and the partly dull feeling I experienced in here.
Summary: I enjoyed myself much in this more than two hours long level although I think the gameplay has potential to improve much as well as a few more and diverse fights could've been added. Both architectural and visual skills of the builder are outstanding especially in the second level in my opinion so putting all those gripes aside it's a well rounded levelset in most aspects, definately recommended - try it out!" - manarch2
Temple of Apollo (8 9 9 8) 47 min, 2 secrets - You start out in a beautifully constructed, if somewhat hazy and low-contrast valley (not my cup of tea as far as visuals go, but I can't deny the technical prowess behind them), which seemingly promises all sorts of non-linear shenanigans, but thankfully doesn't really deliver on that promise - so the progression here is smooth enough. As mentioned, if you've come to expect a certain type of gameplay from the author, you might be surprised about the overall low difficulty level - with arguably the more challenging parts saved for the 4 side quests of the inner temple area. And this is where I'm conflicted - and not just in regards to this particular level of the set. While there's nothing intrinsically wrong with making the gameplay accessible and lean on the easier side - I found it to be a tad too dull and undemanding, actually enjoying myself the most in the more daredevil sidequests. Still, most likely in debt to those more action orientated and challenging sections of the game, this was my favourite level of the three.
Al-Rachun (7 7 8 8) 50 min, 2 secrets - While this has its share of clever moments - using a movable block to access a higher ledge, destroying a plaque using a magical boulder, and a few others - I have to say I found it to be even more tame than the preceding level. True, the slower pace may have been too subtle for me, or may be a matter of taste or a particular mood - but I found that most of the gameplay in here consisted of finding the next switch, with the author's idea of variety being making some of them timed. The looks change from Hellenistic to Egyptian and are well constructed, though the main area is open-ended from the word go, thus either makes this too confusing for those who love some direction or an explorer's dream come true depending on how you look at it.
Inside the Complex (7 8 9 8) 37 min, 2 secrets - More exciting moments to be had at the end - with a wraith chase, running over blades, scaling a boiling water room - though the bulk of gameplay still relies on switches and timed sequences whether they are necessary or not (I did find the one with the demigod and pyramid exciting if you don't opt to take out the demigod first). The author cleverly uses a fire effect to stop you from resolving to the regular TR4 trick of demigod fighting (approach, kneel, fire), and the audio tracks and textures are put to great use, introducing a bit of colour to the monotone, if well done settings (a sun bulb in every room is a must, though the author's skill distracts from their lack quite well for most part). I liked how the course was set up for Lara's escape after she gets the titular feather, sometimes crossing areas you've been to before, and the 2 secrets I found were fun to get.
Overall, I can't stress enough that there's absolutely nothing wrong with the trio of levels as they are, despite my more critical claims, and they are of a high aesthetic and gameplay quality, showcasing the builder's skills quite well. It merely lacked a bit of pizzazz and a couple of 'wow' moments to make it stand out more from the pack for me - and if taking out the more challenging aspects the author is more renown for in his games was in some way a reaction to what he perceives the players want - I'd advise against it in further works, and just embrace that he likes building more challenging gameaplay. Maybe not as many casual players will stick around due to accessibility as a result, but a fair share of others will join in for the sheer amount of creativity they showcase." - eTux